๐Ÿ† Recommendation: Dad's 3.5% loan, $1,250/mo floor, pay extra when the waterfall allows

๐Ÿ’ฐ

Best 30-year outcome

Dad's 3.5% loan at $1,250/mo + investing the freed-up cash yields $2,178,087 net worth at year 30 โ€” +$114,914 over buying a new house, with ~$722k of it liquid.

๐Ÿฆ

Bank construction loan is the worst path

At 6.5% it finishes ~$314k behind Dad's loan, and 104 Harrington is held under Bond for Title โ€” no legal title until payoff, so bank-secured construction loans/HELOCs are effectively unavailable anyway.

โšก

Want less interest? Front-load, don't refinance

At 3.5%, $2,000/mo pays off in 13 yrs with ~$61k interest vs ~$126k at $1,250/mo. Keep the contractual floor low for affordability and prepay voluntarily. Full analysis: ADR-007 and docs/house-loan/ in the repo.

Dad IO (3.5%) Outflow $2,154/mo Never pays off
Dad $1,250/mo Outflow $2,675/mo Paid off in ~25 yrs
Dad $1,500/mo Outflow $2,925/mo Paid off in ~19 yrs
Buy New (20% Down) Net $3,194/mo Net of rent offset

Scenario Comparison

Monthly outflow includes the $1,425/mo Harrington bond payment. 30-yr totals assume no refinancing.

Strategy Scenario Dad Monthly Pmt Total Net Monthly Outflow Payoff Timeline 30-Yr Total Outflow Total Interest Paid